Emily Jashinsky defends Shane Gillis's SNL gym joke
Her After Party commentary draws an unusually large Shorts audience as she disputes criticism of the comedian's monologue.
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 37,788 views a day, 14 times a normal first day on this channel (2,746).
Shane Gillis' SNL Joke About Women Sparks ABSURD Backlash
A joke about women's gym clothes becomes a question about how to read a comedian's persona on After Party with Emily Jashinsky. Jashinsky argues that Shane Gillis's Saturday Night Live material belongs alongside his jokes at his own expense, including a routine about his haircut.
This is a split-screen commentary clip, not Gillis's monologue itself. It drew an estimated 38,000 views in its first day, roughly fourteen times the channel's usual Shorts start.
Jashinsky scrolls through critical posts on X and challenges the suggestion that Gillis bombed. "He did not actually bomb," she says, arguing that the studio audience responded more positively than at his previous appearances. That's her assessment of the performance, rather than a verdict the clip independently establishes.
Her defense goes beyond comic delivery: she argues that the gym-clothing premise reflects something she sees in everyday life. The conversation then shifts from Gillis to expectations around women's sexuality, with her guest questioning whether messages about liberation and modesty fit together. A haircut joke supplies Jashinsky's starting point; competing cultural expectations become the larger subject.
Published on Trari
Where next?
- Subscribers
- 150,000 ▲ 2,000 this week
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 659,524
- Channel views, pace per day
- 66,585 (on a normal day: 94,650)
- Video published
- October 13, 2026
- Video views so far
- 42,557 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 40,935
The numbers
The Gillis commentary drew far more first-day views than a typical After Party Short. Its comment section was also several times busier than usual.
💡 Test your knowledge
In which year did Saturday Night Live premiere?
Saturday Night Live premiered on NBC in October 1975.



